By Syndication Washington Post, Bloomberg · No Author · BUSINESS, WORLD, ASIA-PACIFIC
Credit Suisse Group this month hired a dozen analysts in China, almost half of whom used to work at UBS, which has scooped up more than 40 people from global and local firms. Morgan Stanley has moved a team to the mainland and hired about 20, but also saw six bankers walk out the door, some to local brokers. Along with Goldman Sachs, most foreign firms are seeking to double their headcounts over the next few years.
The hiring follows China's historic opening of its financial sector and stands in contrast to much of the world, with global banks announcing jobs cuts this year exceeding 63,000, on track for the deepest retrenchment since 2015. The industry's biggest players are betting there's billions to be made in China on products from merger advice to stock underwriting and trading - if they can find the right people.
"There's definitely a talent war between some of the big global banks," said Sid Sibal, a Hong Kong-based regional director at recruitment firm Hudson. "In China, there's a finite amount of talent that one can poach from big investment banks, so they're going to have to think out of the box."
Credit Suisse has hired top ranked analyst Alex Liu and Tracey-Ruth Sun from UBS to lead its research operations. Last year it snapped up UBS's head of research, Erica Poon Werkun. The firm pushed out about 30 bankers at the joint venture in July to make room for fresh talent, a person familiar has said.
Beefing up research is becoming crucial as China opens its markets to lure more foreign inflows. It last year scrapped limits on overseas purchases of stocks and bonds and eliminated approvals for quotas. Foreigners hold 4.7% of Chinese stocks in circulation, way below the more than 30% in markets such as Japan's and South Korea's, according to the China Securities Regulatory Commission.
UBS is also on the prowl. The Swiss bank has recruited about 200 people this year, including 44 bankers, analysts and support staffers from at least five brokerages, including Credit Suisse, a spokesman said. UBS transferred managing director Grace Chen from Hong Kong to Beijing to head technology, media and telecommunications banking.
U.S. behemoth Morgan Stanley has seen a churn of bankers. After flying executives in and out of Shanghai over the past years to right its money-losing joint venture it has installed its own personnel in top positions. The firm this year moved seven executives to its China venture, in addition to hiring 20 bankers and research analysts, a person familiar said.
- - -
But it was also hit by departures, with some leaving for China International Capital, underscoring the difficulties foreign banks face. Morgan Stanley lost six bankers at its China venture recently, including two executive directors and another banker who worked on its biggest deal this year, people familiar said. That was in part after it failed to pay bonuses to some executives and bankers but also due to lower deal flows, problems faced by its global rivals as well, the people said.
Morgan Stanley this year ranks first among foreign brokers in China after helping arrange the initial public offering of Semiconductor Manufacturing International the largest ever on Shanghai's Star board, but it lags far behind local rivals such as CICC.
Spokeswomen for UBS, Morgan Stanley and Credit Suisse declined to comment.
Analysts and bankers say that Chinese brokers offer a faster chance at advancing. While an analyst with three years of experience could become a sector chief at a local broker, it takes much longer to climb the ladder at a foreign firm, according to one executive who has worked for both. Stricter compliance at foreign banks is another hurdle. Local brokerages, for example, are allowed to co-invest in Star Market deals they handle, a potentially lucrative practice that is heavily scrutinized at foreign firms.
While it's still hard to compare compensation difference between local and foreign firms, in part because global banks are just getting started, the newcomers are offering at least a 20% bump up to lure candidates for senior roles, said Eric Zhu, head of financial services recruitment at Morgan McKinley. Campus recruitment by foreign firms has grown by double-digits from two years ago, he said.
Some local firms are taking note and adjusting their compensation structure to be more in line with global practice by offering a greater part in fixed salary to graduates and junior hires, he said, but cautioned that recruiting in China is about more than just pay.
"Compensation isn't the most important factor," he said. "Foreign companies don't have much status here; you have to tell a very compelling story for people to be interested."
- - -
There's also the lure of work outside banking. A senior banker who left Morgan Stanley's joint venture this year said he was headhunted by about four corporates. Demand for bankers is climbing as China loosens rules in its capital markets, making it easier to raise funds and go public. While compensation is not as high, the lure of stock options is enticing, he said, declining to be named because he was not authorized to discuss the matter.
But global banks are now betting their expanding investments and increased control will translate into climbing market share, making them a bigger magnet for talent.
Thomas Fang, head of China global markets at UBS, estimated this year that China's brokerage industry will generate revenue of $100 billion by 2025, with foreign capital grabbing 25% of the pie.
Just based on the stated hiring plans by Goldman, UBS and Japan's Nomura Securities, they will need to find at least a 1,000 people over the next few years. JPMorgan Chase has been quiet about its hiring plans, but is expanding by a third its office space in China's tallest skyscraper in Shanghai's business district. Credit Suisse CEO Thomas Gottstein said on Tuesday that the bank plans to double its number of relationship manager in the Asia, as it's rolling out onshore wealth management in China.
"It's not 10, 20 staff anymore," said Sibal. "When you have that level of demand you have to broaden your search."