Sunday, August 09, 2020

Indian islanders vote with sinking hearts

May 19. 2019
Facebook Twitter

By Agence France-Presse
Ghoramara Island, India

Residents on Ghoramara fear that the votes they cast Sunday in India’s election may be the last before their island sinks into the Bay of Bengal – a victim of climate change’s growing toll.

About 4,000 people, including poor fisherman Goranga Dolui, were on the electoral list for the island in the Sunderban delta.

“Those who could, have left already. How will the poor like me leave? We hope the government will help us start a new life,” he says. 

Ghoramara is now about four square kilometres (1.5 square miles) having lost about half its size in the past three decades to rising seas. 

Ghoramara’s voters could still have a role in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s bid for a second term. His Bharatiya Janata Party has campaigned aggressively across West Bengal state and the result in the local constituency is on a knife edge.

But Dolui is pessimistic about his vote and the results to be announced on Thursday changing the future of the island which is only connected to mainland India by a one-hour ferry ride.

“We will keeping living here until we can’t anymore,” he says.

Ghoramara’s election officer Swati Bandopadhyay says the island may be lost in two or three years as the rate of erosion accelerates with each monsoon season.


Climate overshadowed 

“People know this natural process is unstoppable and are gradually moving to the mainland,” she adds. 

Thousands of Ghoramara residents have moved in recent years to Sagar, a bigger island in the delta, or Kakdwip on the mainland. But several islands surrounding islands are threatened. 

Modi held one of his mega election rallies on the West Bengal mainland last week where he talked about security. The environment, however, has not featured in the election battle between the prime minister and opposition leader Rahul Gandhi.

Party manifestos barely mention the melting Himalayan glaciers sending water pouring into the Bay of Bengal, or pollution caused by coal mining, or shrinking forests.

There was little talk of the notoriety of New Delhi and 13 other Indian cities among the world’s 15 cities with the most polluted air.

“Both major parties have sidelined discussion of the environment during the campaign,” explains Aarti Khosla, director of Climate Trends, a New Delhi-based initiative on climate change and clean energy.

“While the public across the world is generating awareness on environmental issues, it is clearly missing in India.”

Critics say the lack of debate on the environment has also clouded discussion on the key areas of agriculture, jobs, water supplies and migration. 

Retired school teacher Satish Chandra Jana, 75, has lived all his life on Ghoramara but is despondent.

“We are struggling to live here and have even constructed a home on Kakdwip,” he says, sat on the deserted village square. 

“I just don’t feel like leaving this place. My heart and life story is connected to this island,” Jana adds. 

The younger generation cannot afford to be as nostalgic as Jana. 

Ghoramara is not connected to India’s electricity grid and relies on unreliable solar energy for power. The disappearing farmland is taking jobs with it.

Tapas Kumar Sasmal, 50, a retired soldier who was born on Ghoramara and returned there to vote, says only about 10 per cent of the original inhabitants remain.

Many who lost their land are now labourers on the mainland. “Life is tough,” he says. 

“Some officials say the island will be gone by the next election. I feel it could happen tomorrow as we are at the mercy of natural disasters.” 

“Everyone wants a safe life,” explains Khushbano Bibi, 41, who is busy cleaning poultry feed outside her small cottage. “We worry all the time that the sea may come.”

“If the government helps, we will move,” she says, while adding that she is pessimistic that anyone in power is 


Facebook Twitter
More in Opinion
Editor’s Picks
Top News