My little screed of January 9 (“Chinese majoritarianism will have dangerous consequences for our region”) seems to have kindled wrath from both sides. Michael Setter excoriates China with a list of the crimes it has committed, and Yingwai Suchaovanich defends it by reciting the usual Chinese Communist Party line.
In response to Michael, I did not claim that China has a great culture that is admirable in every way. I said it has a great culture that is admirable in MANY ways. And I was referring to the entire 5,000-year tradition – not the narrow, contemporary segment currently being trumpeted by the People’s Republic of China and its apologists. I think even Michael will have to admit that lifting so many millions of Chinese people out of poverty in such a short time, despite the attendant evils, is an admirable feat.
In response to Yingwai, I did not claim that China WILL gobble up all of Southeast Asia on the grounds of its substantial population of ethnic Chinese. I said that was where the logical progression of his majoritarian thinking inevitably leads. Despite all his eel-wriggling, Yingwai has never addressed my central thesis, that the Taiwanese people ought to have the right to determine their own destiny.