Netizens in Philippines under watch by 'Five Eyes'
Play
Even without the controversial cybercrime law, Filipino netizens are already under surveillance by the "Five Eyes" spy network exposed by American whistle-blower Edward Snowden, advocates of Internet freedom said.
“Our problem with the law is that it places every netizen under surveillance,” said Marnie Tonson, convenor and legal counsel of the Philippine Internet Freedom Alliance (PIFA), during a Senate hearing on the cybercrime law.
But Assistant Justice Secretary Geronimo Sy doused fears that Republic Act No 10175, or the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012, would be used by the government to place netizens under surveillance.
It would have been a “good problem” if only the government had the “basic capacity” to mount such surveillance, Sy said.
“But remember, in government [offices] we can’t even stock our toilets with toilet paper,” Sy said.
The justice official vowed to post online the Department of Justice-crafted rules and regulations “to invite everyone to put [in their] comments”.
The Supreme Court recently ruled that the online libel provision in the Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 was constitutional, though it struck down another provision that empowers the justice department to restrict or block access to data and websites violating the law.
The high court also clarified that only the original authors of libelous material were covered by the cybercrime law, and not those who merely received or reacted to it.
Bloggers, freedom advocates and journalists have pressed Congress to repeal the cybercrime law that criminalises libel, with some senators adding that libel in the Revised Penal Code should be repealed as well.
For its part, PIFA said Filipino netizens were already under surveillance even without the cybercrime law through the “Five Eyes” network identified by Snowden.
A government official could request any member of the Five Eyes network – Australia, the United States, Great Britain, New Zealand and Canada – to conduct the surveillance, Tonson said.
